Tax Advantages of Being Autónomo vs Starting a Company in Spain: Strategic Choices for Entrepreneurs

Reading time: 13 minutes

Table of Contents

• Introduction: Navigating Spain’s Business Structure Options
• The Autónomo System: Spain’s Self-Employment Framework
• Spanish Business Structures: S.L., S.A., and Beyond
• Tax Comparison: Autónomo vs Company
• Income Thresholds: When Each Option Makes Financial Sense
• Social Security Implications and Long-Term Planning
• Industry-Specific Considerations
• Real-World Examples: Decision Points in Action
• Transition Strategies: From Autónomo to Company
• Conclusion: Making Your Strategic Choice
• Frequently Asked Questions

Introduction: Navigating Spain’s Business Structure Options

Standing at the crossroads of entrepreneurship in Spain, you’re faced with a pivotal decision that will shape your business journey: should you register as an autónomo (self-employed) or establish a formal company? This choice isn’t merely administrative—it carries significant tax implications that directly impact your bottom line.

The Spanish business landscape offers distinct advantages for both paths, but navigating these options requires understanding the nuanced tax frameworks that apply to each. While the autónomo route offers simplicity and lower initial costs, company structures provide potential tax efficiencies at higher income levels. The challenge lies in determining which path aligns with your specific circumstances.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll cut through the complexity to help you make an informed decision based on concrete financial considerations. Rather than dealing in generalizations, we’ll focus on specific income thresholds, deduction opportunities, and long-term planning strategies that determine when each option makes financial sense for your particular situation.

The Autónomo System: Spain’s Self-Employment Framework

The autónomo system represents Spain’s framework for self-employed individuals and serves as the entry point for many entrepreneurs. Let’s examine the key components that define this option:

Tax Structure and Progressive Rates

As an autónomo, your business income is taxed through the IRPF (Impuesto sobre la Renta de las Personas Físicas)—Spain’s personal income tax system. This progressive taxation model means your tax rate increases as your income rises, with 2023 rates ranging from 19% for income up to €12,450 to 47% for portions exceeding €300,000 in certain autonomous communities.

Here’s the critical point many entrepreneurs miss: unlike company taxation, autónomo taxation doesn’t separate business and personal income. Your business profits stack on top of any other personal income sources, potentially pushing you into higher tax brackets more quickly.

Social Security Contributions

Beyond income tax, autónomos face mandatory social security contributions that operate on a different system. Since January 2023, Spain has implemented a new contribution system based on real income brackets, replacing the previous flat-rate approach. Monthly contributions now range from approximately €200 for the lowest income level to over €500 for higher earners.

While these contributions may seem substantial, they provide comprehensive coverage including healthcare, sick pay, maternity/paternity benefits, and contribute toward your future pension. Unlike company structures, these payments are mandatory regardless of whether you turn a profit.

“The new progressive social security system benefits early-stage entrepreneurs while ensuring higher contributions from those with established businesses. It’s a significant shift from the previous model that often placed disproportionate burden on struggling self-employed individuals.” — María García, Tax Advisor at Asesoría Fiscal Barcelona

Spanish Business Structures: S.L., S.A., and Beyond

When entrepreneurs move beyond self-employment in Spain, they typically establish one of several formal business structures, each with distinct tax implications:

Sociedad Limitada (S.L.) — Limited Liability Company

The S.L. represents Spain’s most common company structure for small to medium enterprises, requiring a minimum capital investment of €3,000. From a tax perspective, this structure offers significant advantages:

• Fixed corporate tax rate: Standard 25% on profits, with reduced rates of 15% available for new companies during their first two profitable years
• Separation of personal and company finances: Unlike the autónomo system, your personal income is distinct from company profits
• Dividend taxation: When extracting profits as dividends, these are taxed separately under savings income brackets (19-26% in 2023)
• Enhanced expense deductions: Greater flexibility in claiming business expenses, including more options for vehicle costs, entertainment expenses, and health insurance

The S.L. structure creates a clear legal separation between your personal assets and company liabilities, providing protection that isn’t available to autónomos. However, this comes with increased administrative requirements including formal accounting, annual accounts filings, and corporate governance procedures.

Other Corporate Structures

While the S.L. is most common, other options include:

• Sociedad Anónima (S.A.): Requiring €60,000 minimum capital, typically used by larger businesses with similar tax treatment to S.L.s
• Sociedad Limitada Nueva Empresa (SLNE): A simplified version of the S.L. with streamlined formation processes
• Sociedad Civil (S.C.): A partnership structure where income passes through to partners’ personal tax returns

Each structure carries specific regulatory requirements and compliance costs that must be weighed against potential tax benefits.

Tax Comparison: Autónomo vs Company

Let’s break down the specific tax differences between operating as an autónomo versus through a company structure:

Tax Aspect	Autónomo	Company (S.L.)	Strategic Implication
Base Tax Rate	Progressive: 19-47% (varies by region)	Fixed: 25% (15% for new companies)	Companies have advantage at higher income levels
Social Security	€200-€500+ monthly (income-based)	Approximately €375 monthly for directors	Similar costs, but structure and benefits differ
Profit Extraction	Direct access to business income	Salary + dividends (additional taxation)	Double taxation issue for companies
Loss Treatment	Can offset against other income	Carried forward against future profits	Autónomos have advantage during unprofitable periods
Administrative Costs	€300-€500 annually	€1,500-€3,000+ annually	Significant cost difference impacts early-stage ventures

Beyond these basic comparisons, several nuanced factors influence which structure offers greater tax efficiency:

Deduction Opportunities and Limitations

While both autónomos and companies can deduct legitimate business expenses, companies generally enjoy broader deduction opportunities. Key differences include:

• Vehicle expenses: Companies can more easily deduct full costs of vehicles, while autónomos face limitations unless the vehicle is 100% dedicated to business use
• Home office deductions: Autónomos can claim proportional housing expenses through the estimación directa scheme, though these deductions are heavily scrutinized
• Health and pension plans: Companies can offer tax-advantaged benefits to employee-owners that aren’t available to autónomos
• Entertainment and client relations: Companies face fewer restrictions on deducting client meals and entertainment

Additionally, certain expense types—such as clothing, personal travel with partial business components, and technology with mixed personal/business use—receive more favorable treatment under company structures.

Income Thresholds: When Each Option Makes Financial Sense

Let’s approach the critical question: at what income level does establishing a company become more tax-efficient than remaining an autónomo?

While individual circumstances vary, detailed financial modeling suggests several general thresholds where the calculation shifts:

The €40,000-€60,000 Decision Point

For most entrepreneurs, the approximate tipping point where company structures begin to offer tax advantages falls between €40,000 and €60,000 of annual profit. Below this threshold, the simplicity and lower administrative costs of the autónomo status typically outweigh potential tax savings from incorporation.

This range exists because at these income levels:

1. Personal income tax rates begin reaching 30%+ in most autonomous communities
2. The fixed 25% corporate tax rate (or 15% for new companies) becomes comparatively advantageous
3. The increased administrative costs of maintaining a company (€1,500-€3,000 annually) can be offset by tax savings

Consider this practical example: An entrepreneur earning €55,000 annually in Madrid might pay approximately €16,500 in personal income tax as an autónomo, while the same income structured through a company with optimized salary/dividend distribution might result in combined taxes around €14,000—creating potential savings that offset company maintenance costs.

Optimization Through Salary/Dividend Balance

Company structures offer tax planning flexibility by allowing owners to adjust how they extract profits. The key strategy involves balancing:

• Salary payments: Subject to personal income tax (IRPF) and social security contributions
• Dividend distributions: Taxed under the savings income regime at 19-26%

The optimal balance typically involves paying a salary up to the social security contribution ceiling (around €49,000 in 2023), then taking additional profits as dividends. This approach minimizes social security costs while taking advantage of the lower savings income tax rates.

However, this strategy requires careful execution to avoid scrutiny from tax authorities, who may challenge arrangements where owner-directors take artificially low salaries to minimize tax obligations.

Social Security Implications and Long-Term Planning

Tax efficiency isn’t solely about immediate income taxation—social security contributions significantly impact both your current expenses and future benefits.

Contribution Structures and Future Benefits

One critical distinction between autónomo and company structures involves how social security contributions influence future benefits:

As an autónomo, your contribution level directly affects your future pension and other benefits. The new progressive system means those reporting higher incomes contribute more but also build toward better pension benefits. This creates potential long-term advantages for autónomos who consistently report substantial income.

In a company structure, directors who are also shareholders must register under the special RETA system (Régimen Especial de Trabajadores Autónomos), similar to autónomos. However, the company typically pays these contributions, creating an immediate deductible expense for the business.

“Many entrepreneurs focus exclusively on immediate tax savings without considering the long-term implications for pension rights. This can be a costly oversight, especially for those planning to remain in Spain during retirement.” — Carlos Martínez, Social Security Specialist at Gestión Integral Madrid

The 2023 social security reforms aim to create a more equitable system where contributions better align with actual income, representing a significant improvement for lower-earning autónomos while potentially increasing costs for higher earners.

Industry-Specific Considerations

The optimal business structure often varies by industry, with certain sectors showing clear tendencies toward either autónomo or company models based on their operational realities:

Industries Favoring Autónomo Status

Several professional sectors typically benefit from maintaining autónomo status even at higher income levels:

• Freelance creative professionals: Writers, designers, and artists who require minimal infrastructure and may benefit from income averaging across years
• Independent consultants: Particularly those with low overhead costs and minimal liability concerns
• Seasonal businesses: Operations with significant income fluctuations, where the ability to offset losses against other income provides advantages
• Healthcare practitioners: Many medical professionals operate as autónomos due to specific healthcare sector regulations

The common thread among these industries involves low operational complexity, minimal fixed assets, and reduced liability concerns.

Industries Favoring Company Structures

Conversely, certain sectors typically benefit from company structures regardless of income level:

• E-commerce and retail: Businesses with inventory, multiple suppliers, and potential consumer liability issues
• Technology startups: Ventures seeking external investment or planning for eventual sale
• Construction and manufacturing: Industries with significant equipment investments and worksite liability concerns
• Professional services firms: Accounting, legal, and consulting practices with multiple professionals

These sectors typically involve increased liability exposure, significant capital requirements, or business models that benefit from the credibility and structural advantages of formal incorporation.

Real-World Examples: Decision Points in Action

Let’s examine two real-world scenarios that illustrate how entrepreneurs navigate the autónomo versus company decision:

Case Study 1: Digital Marketing Consultant

Elena, a digital marketing consultant based in Barcelona, began her business journey as an autónomo in 2019. Her income progression illustrates common decision points:

• Year 1 (2019): €28,000 profit — Remained autónomo, benefiting from the flat-rate social security discount for new autónomos
• Year 2 (2020): €42,000 profit — Continued as autónomo despite reaching borderline income levels, due to pandemic uncertainty
• Year 3 (2021): €68,000 profit — Established an S.L. after financial analysis showed potential tax savings of approximately €4,200 annually

Elena’s transition involved careful timing: she incorporated in October 2021, allowing her to close the fiscal year as an autónomo and start fresh as a company in January 2022. This approach avoided the complications of mid-year transitions while enabling her to strategically time certain expense recognitions.

“The decision wasn’t purely financial,” Elena explains. “As my client base expanded to include larger corporations, the S.L. structure provided credibility advantages and opened doors to contracts that were previously challenging to secure as an individual autónomo.”

Case Study 2: Small Architectural Practice

Miguel and Sofia, architects in Valencia, established a partnership that evolved from dual autónomo status to a company structure:

• Initial stage (2017-2019): Both partners operated as individual autónomos, each earning approximately €35,000 annually
• Growth phase (2020): Combined income reached €90,000, prompting consideration of formal structure
• Transition decision (2021): Established an S.L. based on liability concerns and expanding team

The partners were initially reluctant to create a company structure due to increased administrative requirements. However, two factors ultimately influenced their decision:

1. Professional liability insurance costs were significantly lower under a company structure compared to individual policies
2. The ability to hire employees more efficiently through a company framework became essential as they expanded

“We actually delayed the transition longer than was financially optimal,” Sofia acknowledges. “In retrospect, we should have made the move a year earlier, as the tax savings would have outweighed the setup costs sooner than we anticipated.”

Transition Strategies: From Autónomo to Company

For entrepreneurs approaching the income threshold where company structures become advantageous, planning a smooth transition requires strategic foresight:

Timing Considerations

The calendar year plays a significant role in transition planning:

• Optimal timing: Most tax advisors recommend transitioning at the beginning of a calendar year to avoid complicated partial-year calculations
• Year-end planning: Consider accelerating expenses or deferring income in the final autónomo year to optimize tax position
• Asset transfer strategy: Develop a clear plan for transferring business assets to the new entity without triggering unnecessary tax events

Many entrepreneurs establish their company 2-3 months before the planned operational transition, allowing time for administrative setup while continuing to operate as autónomo until the optimal switching date.

Practical Implementation Steps

The transition process typically involves several key stages:

1. Pre-formation analysis: Work with a tax advisor to model specific tax implications based on your actual income patterns
2. Legal formation: Typically involving a notary appointment, banking arrangements, and registration with the commercial registry
3. Operational transfer: Systematically shifting contracts, client relationships, and operational systems to the new entity
4. Initial capitalization: Determining optimal strategies for funding the new company, potentially including asset transfers from your autónomo business
5. Communication plan: Notifying clients, suppliers, and other stakeholders of the structural change

A critical decision point involves determining whether to maintain your autónomo status alongside the new company during a transition period, or to make a clean break. This decision typically depends on contract obligations and client relationship considerations.

Conclusion: Making Your Strategic Choice

The decision between operating as an autónomo or establishing a company in Spain extends far beyond simple tax calculations—it encompasses your business aspirations, risk tolerance, and long-term vision.

For entrepreneurs in early growth stages with annual profits below €40,000, the autónomo framework typically offers the most efficient combination of tax treatment and administrative simplicity. The recent reforms to the social security contribution system have further improved the viability of this option for lower-earning self-employed individuals.

As your business crosses the €40,000-€60,000 profit threshold, company structures begin offering potential advantages that merit serious consideration. However, this transition point isn’t universal—it varies based on your specific income composition, industry requirements, liability concerns, and future growth plans.

Rather than viewing this decision as permanent, successful entrepreneurs approach it as an evolving strategic choice that should be reassessed periodically as their business develops. The optimal approach often involves starting as an autónomo for simplicity, then transitioning to a company structure when financial and operational factors align.

Ultimately, the most tax-efficient business structure is one that not only minimizes immediate tax obligations but also supports your growth objectives, provides appropriate protection, and positions you for long-term success in Spain’s dynamic business environment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I operate simultaneously as an autónomo and through a company?

Yes, it’s legally possible to maintain both structures simultaneously. Some entrepreneurs use this approach during transition periods or when operating distinct business activities. However, tax authorities scrutinize such arrangements carefully to prevent artificial income splitting. If you pursue this strategy, maintain clear separation between the activities of each entity, with distinct client bases, service offerings, and operational systems. Document the business purpose for maintaining dual structures to defend against potential challenges during tax inspections.

How do recent tax reforms affect the autónomo versus company decision?

The 2023 social security reforms significantly impact this calculation by creating a more progressive contribution system for autónomos. Lower-earning self-employed individuals now benefit from reduced monthly contributions, making the autónomo option more attractive at early stages. Simultaneously, recent adjustments to corporate taxation have maintained the general 25% rate while limiting certain deductions. These parallel changes haven’t fundamentally altered the income threshold where company structures become advantageous, but they have improved the financial position of early-stage autónomos relative to small companies.

What specific expenses receive more favorable treatment under company structures?

Companies enjoy broader expense deduction opportunities in several key categories. Vehicle expenses represent perhaps the most significant difference—companies can fully deduct vehicle acquisition, maintenance, and operational costs, while autónomos face substantial limitations unless the vehicle is exclusively for business use. Similarly, companies have greater flexibility in deducting travel expenses with mixed business/personal components, technology investments, client entertainment, and certain insurance products. Additionally, companies can establish tax-advantaged retirement plans and health insurance arrangements for owner-employees that aren’t available to autónomos. These enhanced deduction opportunities often contribute significantly to the tax advantage companies enjoy at higher income levels.